House on Haunted Hill: Collector's Edition [Blu-ray]
Blu-ray A - America - Shout! Factory
Review written by and copyright: Anthony Arrigo (11th November 2018).
The Film

There was a sense of promise that came about when mega-producer Joel Silver and director Robert Zemeckis, along with producer Gilbert Adler, formed Dark Castle Entertainment. The production company planned to focus on remakes of William Castle pictures – this in a time before “remake” was such a vilified term. Let’s also not forget that many of Castle’s pictures were famous more for their showmanship and gimmicks than their quality and content… with the exception of the first film Dark Castle chose to remake, “House on Haunted Hill” (1959). A classic of both the haunted house subgenre and lead actor Vincent Price, this new take on an old story added a few interesting new elements to the tale, though by the end the story pretty much fizzles out. I remember having a blast with this movie and really enjoying it, but my last viewing was probably 15 years ago. Time hasn’t been too kind, and while the first act is still plenty of fun it’s all downhill from there.

1931. A patient uprising at Vannacutt Institute for the Criminally Insane leaves Dr. Vannacutt (Jeffrey Combs) and his staff brutally murdered, while a fire starts within and eventually engulfs the massive building and everyone inside. Cut to present day, where Stephen Price (Geoffrey Rush) is being interviewed by a local news team about his latest endeavor, a gimmick-based rollercoaster. Price is known for his showmanship and bravado. The only person who doesn’t buy his bullshit is Evelyn (Famke Janssen), his loveless wife. Evelyn has instructed Stephen to put together a guest list for her upcoming birthday party, to be held in the remains of the Vannacutt Institute. Price drafts up a list… but then his computer mysteriously erases it and replaces the names with five seemingly random selections.

Later, those same five guests arrive at the institute and meet both Stephen and Evelyn, though everyone is still unsure why they were chosen to attend. Price pays this little mind and lays out the ground rules for the night’s festivities: anyone who can survive an entire night in the mansion leaves $1 million richer. Any who leave forfeit their check and it, too, goes to the winner(s). Not long after Price gives his speech the house goes on lockdown, sealing all the windows and doors with steel plates. Unbeknownst to those in attendance, Price has strategically rigged the house to scare the wits out of anyone who explores it. He isn’t going to make surviving till morning easy. Unbeknownst to Price, however, is the fact the ghosts of Vannacutt Institute are still in residence and their bloodlust has not been sated since that fateful night in 1931.

The setup here is great, just as it was in the original. Director William Malone wisely turned the character Stephen Price into an amalgamation of Vincent Price (just check out that stache) and William Castle, using the former’s appearance and the latter’s flair for theatrics. This allows the film to have plenty of fun – which it does. The opening with Price being interviewed is a highlight, and might even be the best scene in the picture. I still enjoy the Mouseketeer roll call of who’s who once everyone lands in the mansion, though the events get shaky from there because the movie just wastes some key setups, like the ghost of Dr. Vannacutt, the ghost inhabiting the mansion, why these specific people were chosen, etc. Characters take us around the mansion to explore creepy chambers and burned-out rooms, but it’s all in an effort to elicit a few extra scares. Not necessarily a bad thing, but the ending should have brought about a sense of resolution and not just one of “oh, cool, so they managed to get away…”

Speaking of “they”, I had forgotten this movie plays like a who’s who of whose career didn’t make it out of the 90's. With the exception of Janssen and Rush, I can’t recall seeing a single one of these faces past the late 90's; maybe Ali Larter. That isn’t to say these actors aren’t good in their roles. Taye Diggs is a great straight man, coming at every problem with a level head and a sense of calm. Bridgette Wilson excels at playing women who are just annoying enough that once they get some sort of comeuppance you think “yea, that’s about right”. Peter Gallagher does smarmy douchebag so well it’s almost too natural. And then there’s Chris Kattan. Where did that guy go? He’s probably miscast here but his energy is infectious enough and he doesn’t overstay his welcome.

The best casting in the film, outside of Rush, who completely carries the picture every step of the way, is Jeffrey Combs as Dr. Vannacutt. Unfortunately, his role is small and he doesn’t do much past the opening, but he apparently returns for “Return to House on Haunted Hill” (2007) which I have not seen but reviews seem to be extremely unfavorable. Dark Castle pumped out a couple more decent remakes – “Thirteen Ghosts” (2001) and “House of Wax” (2005) – but nothing that could be considered an outright classic or hit. The company has moved away from horror in the past decade, focusing on action and drama.


Horror films from the 90's tend to look a bit flat and soft, but the 1.85:1 1080p 24/fps image is ultra clean and stunningly detailed. The production design of the mansion is richly layered, with many subtleties and ornate patterns. This HD image allows for every minute detail to be seen with strong clarity. Outside of a few soft shots the picture is sharp, offering up lifelike qualities in the image. Colors are rich and solid contrast keeps blacks looking inky and deep.


Sound design is crucial to haunted house films and the English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround sound track capably delivers an immersive experience. The beginning of the picture features minimal use of rear channels, with dialogue and most effects directed to the front. Once the house begins to come alive, so do the corners of the room, creaking with decayed floors and old doors, oohing with ghostly emanations, and exploding when the moment strikes. Bass response is average, with some decent rumbling. Subtitles are available in English.


The disc includes a legacy audio commentary with director William Malone.

“Interview with Director William Malone” (1080p) interview runs for 37 minutes and 30 seconds.

“Interview with Composer Don Davis” (1080p) interview runs for 9 minutes and 40 seconds.

“Interview with Visual Effects Supervisor Robert Skotak” (1080p) interview runs for 18 minutes and 42 seconds.

Concept art and storyboard gallery (1080i) runs for 2 minutes and 53 seconds.

Behind-the-Scenes visual FX gallery (1080i) runs for 5 minutes and 44 seconds.

Movie stills and poster gallery (1080i) runs for 4 minutes and 37 seconds.

"A Tale of Two Houses" is a vintage featurette (SD) runs for 19 minutes and 14 seconds.

"Behind the Visual FX" is another vintage featurette (SD) runs for 7 minutes and 1 second.

A reel of deleted scenes (SD) runs for 12 minutes and 4 seconds.

The theatrical trailer (SD) runs for 2 minutes and 13 seconds.

Two TV spots (SD) run for 1 minute and 5 seconds.


The single disc comes housed in a standard Blu-ray keep case. The cover art is reversible. A slip-cover with the new art is included on first pressings.


Not as fun as I remembered it, “House on Haunted Hill” has a great first act and a handful of decent moments making it worth a watch, especially if you were weaned on 90's horror. The second act-lag leads to a crumbling finale, with some badly dated CGI, but the film’s tongue stays planted in its cheek firmly enough to mostly work.

The Film: B- Video: A- Audio: A- Extras: A Overall: B


DVD Compare is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and the Amazon Europe S.a.r.l. Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to,,,, and